ABL Live-Tweets the #ACA Oral Arguments, Day 1

What started out as a "maybe I'll live-tweet as I listen to the oral arguments hahaha" idea turned into a four hour project. I think I'll mark up the transcript with the must-read parts and upload that onto Scribd. There are some parts that you should read, but no one really wants to read a 100 page transcript. Except lawnerdz me, that is. UPDATE: Here's the scribd link: http://www.scribd.com/doc/86983424/Mar-27-ACA-Hearing-Transcript-ABL-mark-up
obamacare aca tfy hcr ablc abl
3644 View 0 comments
Login and hide ads.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:27:25 WIB
Maybe I should live blog me listening to this oral argument. hahaha
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:27:13 WIB
Roberts asks whether or not the govt could force you to by a cell phone for easier access to emergency services. Uh... WHAT?! #analogyfail
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:36:30 WIB
Roberts still returning to his hypothetical. When you need emergency services, the government makes sure you get it. (1)
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:37:08 WIB
When you need healthcare, the government makes sure you get it. (2)
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:37:34 WIB
Uh... except having a cell phone is not critical to the provision of emergency services. WHy would govt mandate that? (3)
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:38:33 WIB
Also, nobody every went bankrupt after the police came to help them out of a jam the way ppl do when they end up in ER w/ no insrnce. (4)
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:39:20 WIB
(I'm live-tweeting this. Justices always ask crazy hypotheticals. This doesn't really mean anything one way or other. I'm only 5 mins in.)
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:43:13 WIB
Verrilli responds that there's no market for emergency services. So here comes Alito with a weird analogy about burial services and ins.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:44:06 WIB
ALito asks if there's a market for burial services, why shouldn't we force ppl to buy burial ins. instead of shifting cost to other ppl.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:45:18 WIB
Verrilli's response to Alito is muddled so far. Alito saying everyone needs healthcare, everyone will be buried. Uh...
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:45:53 WIB
All People only need to buried ONCE. Can't be determined in advance how much healthcare a person will need.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:47:40 WIB
Verrilli points out that with HC, the costs of uninsured are transferred directly to other market participants. Not so with burial services.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:51:13 WIB
Alito says the mandate not about requiring ppl to pay for care they will consume, but it forces young hlthy ppl to subsidize others care.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:51:52 WIB
R.B. Ginsberg (IN DA HOUSE) interrupts and says " but that's what insurance is." She shoots! She scores!
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:55:49 WIB
Guess what? If I went back to being a lawyer, I wouldn’t be able to live-tweet these oral arguments. *ahem* http://t.co/HeedfsiB #p2 #TFY
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:56:30 WIB
And by “live-tweet” I mean “as I listen to them.” Duhvs.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:57:59 WIB
Kenendy asks if there is a heavy burden of justification for forcing people into a market. Verrilli's answer is brillz....
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:59:06 WIB
We're just regulating participation in HC market. Instead of requiring insurance at point of sale, just requiring it in ADVANCE. Schawing!
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 01:59:36 WIB
[Seriously. Everyone needs healthcare at some point. Just pay for it NOW when it's cheaper instead of LATER when it's fucking expensive.]
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:01:41 WIB
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:02:39 WIB
Scalia asked why hc market defined so broadly as "healthcare". Not everyone needs a heart or liver transplant. DUH?! RISK POOLING!!!11
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:05:29 WIB
Verrilli says food market isn't the same. Obvs. You don't wander into Safeway and are given broccoli even if you can't pay for it. #eyeroll
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:07:42 WIB
I love Ruthie B. She just interrpted Verrilli and was all "I thought your main point was..." and then made the argument he shld be making.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:08:28 WIB
RBG's point is, even if you have every intention of self-insuring, if disaster strikes, you don't have the money, then errrybody else pays.
Imani Gandy o—€ @AngryBlackLady 28/03/2012 02:11:03 WIB
Justice Breyer wants to talk about burial services again. Also starts making Verrilli's argument for him. Verrilli's kinda fucking it up.
Load Remaining (125)

Bookmarked tags

No tags
Login and hide ads.