An Unjustified attack on Japanese manga and anime (Responses to BBC Three)

The responses to "Young Sex for Sale in Japan" (Stacey Dooley). Child sexual abuse is a serious problem, but attacking manga and anime culture is ethnocentrism.
53
BBC Three @bbcthree

Does Japan have a serious problem with sexualising children? @StaceyDooley investigates in her latest doc. pic.twitter.com/qA5PXzJrvp

01/03/2017 03:01:05 WIB
URL BBC iPlayer Stacey Dooley Investigates, Young Sex for Sale in Japan Stacey Dooley examines Japan's problem with the sexualisation of children. 1 user 1119

Counterarguments

MattvonB @mattvonbe

@bbcthree @StaceyDooley Does England have a serious problem with child rape? #Rotherham ...you didn't need to go to Tokyo

01/03/2017 04:04:08 WIB
鈴折 @sin_Lv98

England seems to rape more children than Japan which you blame about lolita manga. #Rotherham @bbcthree @StaceyDooley

02/03/2017 22:45:21 WIB
鈴折 @sin_Lv98

Why? Logical people shouldn't ban fictions invading no children's rights just because of your discomfort. That's all @bbcthree @StaceyDooley

02/03/2017 23:01:12 WIB
鈴折 @sin_Lv98

If there are people who ban it, it turns out that that people are illogical and foolish. @bbcthree @StaceyDooley

02/03/2017 23:06:05 WIB
鈴折 @sin_Lv98

And inteviewee Dan Kanemitsu deposed that BBC3 has cut off adverse Supreme Court comment he provided.@bbcthree @StaceyDooley

02/03/2017 23:37:37 WIB

Source of information is this tweet↓

兼光ダニエル真C98三日目と01b @dankanemitsu

BBC3のドキュメンタリーで子供が強姦されたりするマンガを読むのはどんな人間と言う質問に対して米国最高裁の二次児ポ禁止違憲判断で提示した「未成年者への的性的欲求が違法性が無い創作物で満足するなら、実在児童のコンテンツ生産が減る」論を紹介したら編集されて私だけの主張になってる……

02/03/2017 23:00:16 WIB
鈴折 @sin_Lv98

This Supreme Court decision in USA denied that lolita mangas harmed actual children. @bbcthree @StaceyDooley

02/03/2017 23:48:36 WIB
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES: JOHN D. ASHCROFT, ATTORNEY GENERAL, et al., PETITIONERS v. THE FREE SPEECH COALITION et al.

"few pornographers would risk prosecution for abusing real children if fictional, computerized images would suffice. Moreover, even if the market deterrence theory were persuasive, the argument cannot justify the CPPA because, here, there is no underlying crime at all."

"It argues that the CPP A is necessary because pedophiles may use virtual child pornography to seduce children. There are many things innocent in themselves, however, such as cartoons, video games, and candy, that might be used for immoral purposes, yet we would not expect those to be prohibited because they can be misused. The Government, of course, may punish adults who provide unsuitable mate-"

"The government "cannot constitutionally premise legislation on the desirability of controlling a person's private thoughts." Stanley v. Georgia, 394 U. S. 557, 566 (1969). First Amendment freedoms are most in danger when the government seeks to control thought or to justify its laws for that impermissible end. The right to think is the beginning of freedom, and speech must be protected from the government because speech is the beginning of thought."

Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

Was going to draw today, then BBC put out another shitty “documentary” on child abuse in Japan.

04/03/2017 21:39:32 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

I do wish they’d do actual research journalism on this, instead of dropping some random journo in Tokyo and having them gasp over eromanga

04/03/2017 21:41:21 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

Yes, there’s children in Japan who are sexually abused and need help. You don’t help them by conflating everything you see >

04/03/2017 21:43:30 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

> into one big mess of “fucked up Japanese shit” for your UK viewers to tut-tut over. Help real children. The cartoons don’t need you.

04/03/2017 21:44:55 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

And if you think that sex crimes in manga directly cause sex crimes in real life, please start protesting every media depiction of any crime

04/03/2017 21:46:15 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

I know that sex crimes are uniquely abhorrent, especially those against children. But we have to keep a cool head here

04/03/2017 21:47:40 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

Media and reality are related, but sex crimes in media don’t directly cause sex crimes IRL any more than thefts in media cause thefts IRL.

04/03/2017 21:48:38 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

If the point is to help children who are being sexually abused, which I sure hope it is, then keep a cool head. Focus on actual problems

04/03/2017 21:50:02 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

People don’t go out and abuse a child because they read a manga, any more than they go out and rob a casino because they saw Ocean’s Eleven

04/03/2017 22:02:23 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

Documentaries like this offer facile “explanations” for child abuse to draw eyeballs for foreign media. Not to help Japanese children.

04/03/2017 22:05:14 WIB
Dr. Nele Noppe/ネラ・ノッパ🇪🇺🏳️‍🌈 @unjapanologist

A few quick thoughts on the newest BBC documentary fiasco. Basically the Japanese version of my earlier thread, with more erghh twitter.com/jfsribbon/stat…

04/03/2017 22:31:02 WIB
Load Remaining (49)

Comment

鈴折 @sin_Lv98 05/03/2017 00:44:30 WIB
I get to know that Japan's "togetter" is called "Chirpstory" in English service for the first time.
4
蒼眼鏡👓 @yoshidatakeshi0 05/03/2017 14:32:28 WIB
for 1970 to 1990 , recorded rape victims are to 1/10 ,in JAPAN .BBC say "Incleasing chuld porn comics ,Incleasing child rape victims " It's fake. who's dreaming ?
5
蒼眼鏡👓 @yoshidatakeshi0 05/03/2017 14:34:36 WIB
Banning japanese porn-comic is no-meaning .
4
シンボリタクジ @symbolix 05/03/2017 16:29:25 WIB
Here's a static data by an organization belonging to U.N.( in 2013) : number of sexual crimes against children (AV. in 100,000 psns ): - Japan : 4,515 cases (22.4) - U.K : 24,256 (199.0) - Germany: 12437(93.6) - France: 16,581(118.6)
4
シンボリタクジ @symbolix 05/03/2017 16:31:49 WIB
Average of U.K. is higher than those of JPN by 8.8 times. Does people of U.K read Japanese comics so diligently?
5
シンボリタクジ @symbolix 05/03/2017 16:40:03 WIB
She and BBC hate Japanese geeks culture & want to express such ideas and feelings, it's O.K.. I'm not gonna interfere with them. however we cannot overlook their intentional misleading related with sexual crimes. It's fake absolutely.
5
緑川⋈だむ @Dam_midorikawa 05/03/2017 20:18:51 WIB
Why does Japan have to listen to inferior countries such as Britain that sexual crime often occurs, which is an excellent country,Japan with few sexual offenses
1
ChanceMaker @Singulith 05/03/2017 20:30:21 WIB
A terrible Japanese hate and fake news by BBC.
3
藍矢 @Aiya_ayiA 05/03/2017 21:28:05 WIB
英日ハーフで英国在住、漫画のすきないとこが差別されているのではないかと心配になる。
0
Rogue Monk @Rogue_Monk 06/03/2017 02:43:06 WIB
When you think someone is wrong, you should consider one more possibility. "Maybe he is right, and I am wrong."
1
くみちす ⋈(3D生主) @ahoaho1313 07/03/2017 16:22:06 WIB
わしゃ よーわからんが反論ありがとう  I do not understand English. refutation.Thank you
1
🔞teru@ASD @teru_s99 07/03/2017 19:43:44 WIB
Learn English so that you can protest weird opinion told by people in Commonwealth countries.
0
Vishal Tyagi @Vishal150217 19/12/2018 14:57:10 WIB
If you need to play tank trouble free online games so here we are having one of the safe and secure platform http://tanktrouble.xyz where you will be able to find out these games in the best quality at different amazing levels.
0