Abortion, Murder, and the #OccupySeattle Miscarriage

A conversation about questions of murder, person-hood, and abortion. Centred on the woman whose unborn child was aborted by police brutality at #OccupySeattle. The discussion was quite quick, so the tweets are perhaps a bit jumbled. I arranged them as clearly as I could.
miscarriage murder abortion
0
Kathy Randall @KathyAngel2
When a pregnant protester miscarries from cops misdeeds, who should pay? @KGW @KeithOlbermann http://t.co/lKgJNH77
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@KathyAngel2 Tricky situation. Could call it murder, but then what about abortion? Rock and a hard place, it seems. @KGW @KeithOlbermann
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
So before anyone starts saying "Cops murdered that #OccupySeattle woman's unborn child", think about your position on abortion. ^_^
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@astriddare You're welcome. It's a teachable moment. Either we can abort unborn kids and cops get away with causing miscarriage, or not.
@astriddare
@timeoutcorner I couldn't find nice words for it, but I feel the same way. Seems like laughable hypocrisy, tbh.
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@astriddare Sigh.... yeah. It's uncomfortable. I favour abortion, and my knee-jerk reaction was "murder". But then I thought about it. :
Rose Bellitzia @RoseBellitzia
@timeoutcorner @astriddare um. explain a little more.having.brain.freeze.on.this one..
@astriddare
@RoseBellitzia @timeoutcorner Some of the most outraged about the miscarriage possibly caused by police are also the strongest pro-choice.
@LizzieCady
@timeoutcorner Wait, but abortion is a woman's choice. Being kicked in the stomach is not.
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@LizzieCady Correct. The mother suffered aggravated assault and should sue. I hope she does! But the miscarried isn't murder.
#tacorevolutionary @JustSikko
@timeoutcorner i dont think having an abortion and someone causing you to have a miscarriage are the same thing one is a choice one is force
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@AnonSikko Oh, not at all. Mother suffered aggravated assault. But the miscarriage isn't murder because that would mean abortion = murder.
@LizzieCady
@timeoutcorner Ohh, I get what you're saying. Still, it's dreadful and it makes me so sad/mad.
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@LizzieCady Same here. As I told @astriddare my first reaction was 'murder'. But this smacks headlong into a very thorny issue.
@CalebNewz
@timeoutcorner @AnonSikko @astriddare Which many would agree with, the assertion that abortion = murder (the living thing has been created)
@CalebNewz
@timeoutcorner @AnonSikko @astriddare if it's proven that the miscarriage was from the assault. Then yes, it'… (cont) http://t.co/wFKErjsp
@astriddare
@CalebNewz @timeoutcorner @AnonSikko You can't prove that though. She could have miscarried just because of stress.
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@CalebNewz Your argument is predicated upon an unborn child being legally a person. Which would illegalise abortion. @AnonSikko @astriddare
@LizzieCady
@timeoutcorner Dammit. I get what you're saying. I think it's important to think about that kind of language.
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@LizzieCady Oh yes. A problem. If, say, liberals conceded: foetises are people, then corporations could be made illegal. Food for thought.
@LizzieCady
@timeoutcorner Hmm that is an interesting thought. REALLY thorny issue!
Red Seeker @timeoutcorner
@LizzieCady Yes, very. As I've noted to others, care must be taken here. The situation is extremely complex, and fraught with many pitfalls.
#tacorevolutionary @JustSikko
@timeoutcorner idk about this cause this would mean we could go around punching prego women in the stomachs all day long
Load Remaining (43)

Comment

No comments yet. Write yours!

Login and hide ads.