When Should Black Feminists Ignore Their Detractors

When Joan Morgan wonders why she hesitated to respond to a Black woman who attacked Black feminists with the same gusto she did the psuedo-science of Satoshi Kanawaza, she sparks a discussion with Jamilah Lemieux, Regina N. Bradley and myself.
1
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

I read the stupidest blog yesterday written by a black woman on why black feminism was ruining black women's chances for relationships...

18/06/2011 00:00:31 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

Not all feminism is bad. The good kind focuses on equal rights but the bad feminism (black feminism) has black women single and unhappy...

18/06/2011 00:01:43 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

Ish was dumb and infuriating but it does have me wondering about why I had no problems responding w a feminist body slam to Kanazawa's...

18/06/2011 00:03:22 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

Obvious racism and not this ridiculous erroneous blog which actually speaks directly to the pop. I care most about - young black women.

18/06/2011 00:04:42 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy I hear you. One thing that makes me pause to respond is the fear of giving people like that credibility with my attention.

18/06/2011 00:14:07 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy I used to believe that I HAD to respond to, be on panels with and otherwise engage, telling myself that we had+

18/06/2011 00:15:33 WIB
Zora Neale Thirston @redclayscholar

@milfinainteasy Gwen Pough posted it on her FB wall and I was scared to read it because I'm working on seizing my inner she-hulk....smh

18/06/2011 00:15:47 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy the same audience so it was necessary for me to do so. A mentor made me rethink this when she told me how she readily pulls

18/06/2011 00:16:54 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy out of panels if she learns that certain people are on it because her presence would give opportunists legitimacy.

18/06/2011 00:21:23 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

That really got me think more deeply about using my time, energy and visibility more strategically. How canI reach that same audience+

18/06/2011 00:24:02 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy without dignifying and amplifying certain folks by stepping on their turf. Especially when the rules of engagement have+

18/06/2011 00:25:25 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy already been set and in a manner to heavily tilt the discourse in their favor. It's not discourse. It's propraganda.

18/06/2011 00:27:06 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy as such, who does it really speak to? Most likely those who have already drank the Kool Aid.

18/06/2011 00:28:30 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy In blunt terms, why lend that errant chick YOUR hard-earned platform to rally HER base?

18/06/2011 00:30:34 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

@redclayscholar me too. But the question is would we hold black on someone else espousing the same nonsense who wasn't black and female?

18/06/2011 01:07:39 WIB
Zora Neale Thirston @redclayscholar

@milfinainteasy nice word play there....battle lines are drawn in the sand...they shift to whatever's convenient, I suppose

18/06/2011 01:08:40 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

@sofiaquintero point well taken but I also feel like that's the population we fight for no? Young women who are struggling with the term?

18/06/2011 01:12:49 WIB
Jamilah Lemieux @JamilahLemieux

@milfinainteasy @sofiaquintero I'm appreciating your thoughts, ladies. I take issues w most of this particular girl's articles

18/06/2011 01:13:10 WIB
Jamilah Lemieux @JamilahLemieux

@milfinainteasy @sofiaquintero and once had a rebuttal posted to her on that same site. I think that b/c she and I are (seemingly) close in

18/06/2011 01:14:10 WIB
Joan Morgan, Ph.D @milfinainteasy

I also feel like in some ways black feminism concedes valuable ground to idiots like Steve Harvey when we font address relationships.

18/06/2011 01:14:46 WIB
Jamilah Lemieux @JamilahLemieux

@milfinainteasy @sofiaquintero age,I feel okay w responding b/c I think we still need much more feminist discourse to motivate my generation

18/06/2011 01:15:05 WIB
Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero

@milfinainteasy I hear you, sis! I'm thinking we have to reach them on our terms, proactively, through our own work, on the ground+

18/06/2011 01:16:18 WIB
Jamilah Lemieux @JamilahLemieux

@milfinainteasy @sofiaquintero Most BW across race lines haven't truly considered feminism and I'm not ok w her (cont) http://tl.gd/b65c6i

18/06/2011 01:16:50 WIB
Zora Neale Thirston @redclayscholar

@sistertoldja @milfinainteasy @sofiaquintero That and continuously refreshed idea of what feminist thought entails..I've read some places...

18/06/2011 01:17:14 WIB
Load Remaining (122)

Comment

Sofia Quintero @sofiaquintero 19/06/2011 00:32:59 WIB
The discussion continues with concerns for strategy, accountability and historical accuracy. And fashion, of course.
0
Blanche Dubois @SugarKovalczyk 19/06/2011 13:03:07 WIB
Thank you for the deep thoughts http:// tl.gd/b6s245 (if this has been posted here before, sorry and please delete)
0